Hmm. They both have merits. I like the detail in the top one, but the bottom one is a much colder image. Hmm.
And I'm not sure why Googlemail thinks my name is X. This is Cleodhna. Sorry!
frame one has a kinda word carved penny dreadful look to it....both are fab tho'
Can't say why, exactly, (as in it would take me ages and Red Riding is back on again in a moment) but I would go for the second one.